Recent Headlines
- Business rates avoidance up for review 23/01/2015
- New era of opportunity 15/01/2015
- Can 2015 live up to expectations? 07/01/2015
- Prop-Search advises motorsport legend 23/12/2014
- How the wind doth blow 22/12/2014
- Permitted development rights….the story so far 16/12/2014
- Relaxation of planning rules for click and collect 10/12/2014
- Bubbling with expansion in Milton Keynes 04/12/2014
- A rates relief for businesses 03/12/2014
- Lift off 02/12/2014
News
Business Rates Mitigation - Boxing Clever
A recent High Court ruling will provide significant relief for landlords struggling with vacant commercial space says commercial property agent Prop-Search, as it confirms that, under current law, structured rates mitigation schemes remain lawful, even when their sole purpose is financial relief.
In the recent case of The Mayor and Commonality and Citizens of the City of London v 48th Street Holding Limited & Anor, decided on 15 May 2025, the High Court addressed significant issues surrounding the legal framework of non-domestic property rates and the complexities introduced by rate mitigation schemes.
At the heart of the case was a rates mitigation scheme for an empty property, temporarily occupying vacant office floors with boxes for six-week intervals – current legislation has increased this period to 13 weeks. This brief period of occupation triggered a three-month exemption from empty property rates. The cycle was repeated, significantly reducing the rates liability for the landlord, 48th Street Holding Ltd.
The City of London argued the scheme was purely artificial and should be invalidated and treated as tax avoidance. However, the High Court found the occupation in this case to be lawful, genuine, and consistent with established case law. The judge emphasised that the benefit derived from the occupation, even if purely for rate savings, was sufficient to meet legal definitions of rateable occupation.
While the government has tightened the rules in England – extending the qualifying occupation period to 13 weeks from April 2024 – it has not outlawed such schemes. Until further legislative change, landlords retain a lawful and practical method to reduce the financial burden of holding empty property in a challenging commercial market.





