A watery risk


A watery risk

It may come as a surprise to both landlords and tenants that they have a liability for the management of risk of exposure to Legionella bacteria in water supplies within their premises says commercial property agent Prop-Search; an area of risk that is often overlooked.

Under the Health & Safety at Work Act 1974, any person in control of premises is responsible for health and safety, and this extends to the potential risk of exposure to legionella bacteria and the associated health risks.

Chris Billson, a Director at Prop-Search, said: “Where a commercial property has communal facilities that are used by tenants and/or members of the public, the landlord has a responsibility to ensure that they are assessed for the risk of exposure to Legionella and regularly monitored to manage any risk identified to prevent the possibility of exposure.  Similarly, tenants have a responsibility for the same risk assessment and management in circumstances where they have facilities within their demise that are used by their staff and/or members of the public.”

The most common areas of risk are water systems that produce a spray, such as showers, cooling towers, spray taps and decorative fountains, but there can also be a risk where there is standing water in pipes or taps where water flow is infrequent.  Water temperature is also a key factor, and one of the variables that should be monitored in relation to taps and other sources of water.  Water temperature between 20 and 45 centigrade poses a risk for the growth of Legionella bacteria.

Chris Billson adds: “As a property owner, employer or person in control of premises, you should be aware of this aspect of Health & Safety and take the necessary measures to ensure your duties are met.  As with fire, dealing with the risk of exposure to Legionella requires the appointment of a competent person with the necessary skills, knowledge and experience to identify, manage and control the risk effectively, and there are specialist contractors that can undertake this task.”

Prop-Manage – the commercial property management arm of Prop-Search – prides itself in providing an exemplary property management service to its clients.  As part of the property management service, Prop-Manage can administer Legionella risk assessments on behalf of commercial landlords by the appointment of appropriate contractors as part of its management service.

If you have an enquiry relating to the ongoing management of a commercial property or wish to discuss the appointment of a managing agent, please contact Chris Billson or David Robbins on 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Monday, August 15, 2016


Ruling could be an inconvenience for takeaways


Ruling could be an inconvenience for takeaways

A recent High Court decision may have significant implications for takeaway food stores that also provide an element of seating for customers says commercial property agent Prop-Search.

The case, involving the bakery chain Gregg’s, was brought by Kingston-Upon-Hull City Council, which argued that the provision of seating for customers within the premises necessitated the provision of toilet accommodation for those customers.  The Council was initially unsuccessful, but on appeal to the High Court, their view was upheld.

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director at Prop-Search, said; “The case was brought under the provisions of Section 20 of the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976 which provides for the requirement of sanitary facilities in certain circumstances.  This allows local authorities to require the provision of toilets at places of entertainment or other ‘relevant places’, and to maintain them.  ‘Relevant places’ include places where food or drink is sold to members of the public for consumption at that place. 

Guidance, however, suggests that ‘food premises’ which are predominantly a take-away operation – where customers are not encouraged to stay and consume food for a significant length of time, and provide less than 10 seats for occasional use by customers (i.e. where consumption on the premises tends to be the exception rather than the rule) – would not generally be regarded as a ‘relevant place’ within the meaning of the Act.  Therefore they would not normally be expected to provide toilet accommodation for customers.

This guidance is used by many food and drink retailers which have entered into a primary authority scheme arrangement (PAS).  PAS is used by businesses to get a degree of certainty over the legal parameters within which they must operate, without being subjected to enforcement policies that might be adopted by individual local authorities.

In this case Newcastle City Council was registered as Greggs’ ‘primary authority’ under PAS and had advised Greggs that its shops were not ‘Relevant Places’ and therefore not required to provide toilet facilities.  However, Hull City Council issued Notices requiring Greggs to provide toilet facilities in two of its premises which Greggs failed to comply with.  As Gregg’s primary authority, Newcastle City Council exercised its power to direct Hull City Council not to proceed with enforcement action.

Accordingly, Hull City Council referred the matter to the Better Regulation Delivery Office (BRDO) who endorsed Newcastle City Council’s advice.  Hull City Council then applied for a judicial review of this decision. 

The case proceeded to the High Court where Mr Justice Kerr held that Newcastle City Council’s advice was in fact wrong.  He considered that it was irrelevant that most customers took their food away as was the fact that the stores had less than 10 seats – if the shops sold food and drink for consumption on the premises they were ‘Relevant Places’.  He reportedly added: “It is obvious that if a person sits down in a Greggs outlet at the seats provided and proceeds to eat a pasty and a fizzy drink just purchased at the counter for that purpose, that is a normal use of the premises.  The fact that most customers take away their purchases and those who stay do not normally stay long, does not change that.”

Hull City Council may now re-serve Notices on Greggs requiring it to provide toilet facilities in the two stores in question.  Greggs can appeal to the County Court to modify or quash the Notices on the grounds that they are unfair or unreasonable but if not successful, a prosecution for failing to comply with the Notice is likely to follow – unless Greggs provides the required facilities within the period specified by the Notice or removes seating from the relevant shops.

Samantha Jones concludes: “Many local authorities have incorporated the 10 seat threshold and predominantly take-away business test into their own guidance.  In light of this High Court ruling many may now look to revise their guidance and we could see an increase in the number of Notices being served requiring the installation of toilets.”

So unless the decision is appealed and the ruling reversed, anyone considering opening a food or drink business are advised to carry out thorough due diligence and consider any guidance published by the relevant local authority and the relevant British Standard BS6465-1:266 + A1:209 – this recommends establishments with up to 25 seats should provide at least one wheelchair accessible unisex toilet.

Certainly, more consideration should now be given to the provision of toilets in takeaway stores than may previously had been the case!

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 or 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Friday, July 29, 2016


New business park nearing completion – Kettering


New business park nearing completion – Kettering

The speculative construction of a new 44,400 sq ft business park in Kettering is now well advanced reports commercial property agent Prop-Search, with the first phase just having been completed and the second phase due for completion imminently.

The new 13 unit scheme – Pytchley Business Park – is located only a mile from Junction 9 of the A14 in a well-established business location.  The Park’s owner, Jelmac Property Group, last year announced that it has secured the first pre-let to a family-owned removal and storage company for a new bespoke facility comprising 10,000 sq ft and subsequently a further 3,500 sq ft has also been let. 

Mark Spooner, a Director of Jelmac Property Group, said: “It is great to see the first phase of units completed at the Park and to welcoming the first tenant taking occupation.  The units offer occupiers, who have to date been unable to find suitable premises, an excellent opportunity to secure brand new quality space on the outskirts of Kettering and play an important role in supporting economic development in the area.”

Pytchley Business Park is being constructed by Tungsten Properties and offers business units of between 2,200 sq ft and 10,000 sq ft.  Letting agent Prop-Search is currently in discussions with a number of other parties looking to make a commitment within the development.

Richard Baker, a Director at retained letting agent Prop-Search, added: “The schemes highly visibly position from the A14 and shortage of quality stock in the area has resulted in an extraordinary level of interest.  Now that interested parties can see the scale and quality of the space available, and that the units are nearing completion, we expect to start converting these enquiries into deals.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

 

Thursday, June 30, 2016


Buoyant year leaves a shortage of stock


Buoyant year leaves a shortage of stock

The lack of available business space in Wellingborough is thwarting economic development in the Borough considers commercial property agent Prop-Search.

Positively, there has been a continued rise in occupier and investment demand but the common theme – like many towns across the UK – is there is a shortage of good quality stock coming to the market.  This is greatly worrying. 

Wellingborough’s industrial market was the standout performer in 2015, across all sectors, with take-up exceeding that of the previous few years.  However, this has resulted in the lowest stock levels since 2007.  The shortage of commercial property has led to demand out-striping supply and combined with increasing build costs, is driving up rents, capital values and land values.

This looks set to continue throughout the reminder of 2016.

Small to medium sized units of good quality are particularly under severe shortage and properties coming onto the market generate interest almost instantly.  And in most cases do not hang around for long.  An example of this is on the Leyland Trading Estate where Northern Trust has demonstrated its commitment to the town, with a substantial investment into the complete refurbishment of eight industrial/warehouse units.  Four of these have been pre-let to existing expanding occupiers within the Estate. 

The only way in which Wellingborough can sustain business growth is through development. 

The process of building stock would generate extra investment in the local economy and jobs, both in the physical construction and post-construction in new business occupation.  We estimate from our own data that there is currently in excess of 500,000 sq ft of latent demand from Wellingborough’s existing occupier market.  Providing a new home for these businesses would obviously release their existing premises to the market and at a more competitive level than new build properties.

So the big questions now are: where will the tranche of new stock come from and who will the developers be? 

Wellingborough’s planned development program is fundamentally replying on two locations; Park Farm West through Prologis and Stanton Cross – specifically Finedon Road – through St Modwen.  The issue with Park Farm West is that the over-riding focus in terms of industrial development is on large format buildings – units over 100,000 sq ft.  This will do very little for existing Wellingborough occupier demand. 

The overall picture in terms of existing occupier demand is typically for buildings of between 20,000 sq ft to 100,000 sq ft.  This is complemented by a sector of growth from new and SME businesses, where again, demand outstrips supply for buildings of between 1,000 sq ft and 20,000 sq ft.  Likewise, these sectors may not be satisfied through the development of Park Farm West or Stanton Cross.

So unsurprisingly, there is concern that industrial growth within Wellingborough is facing challenging times

What is really needed is the development of another Park Farm Industrial Estate, providing buildings for start-up businesses through to local businesses expanding.  Large format occupier demand – over 100,000 sq ft – can be addressed through Park Farm West and Stanton Cross, but there is significant competition in this sector from other schemes within the County, some of which are far better located in terms of access to the national road network. 

Wellingborough’s success over the last 30 years has been driven by the delivery of well-planned and developed employment space – crucially meeting market demand.  It remains a very popular location in the centre of the Midlands and serviced by an excellent and improving road and rail network.  However, without a radical and prompt rethink, neighbours such as East Northants and Kettering will effectively steal Wellingborough’s market share – something already seen in other sectors such as retail where, for example, East Northants has secured one of the largest new retail developments in England with Rushden Lakes.

Similar pressures exist on Wellingborough’s deliverable supply of housing, where again districts like East Northants have around 10 years deliverable supply and Wellingborough has less than five years. 

There are potentially tough times ahead for Wellingborough, but the fundamental metrics for the town are strong – it has the ability to thrive as it did in the late 80s.  But in a region where so much growth is anticipated, there is much to be gained from working more closely with neighbouring towns.  More co-ordination between Local Authorities would deliver a more balanced mix of employment across all sectors – meeting modern occupier requirements and complimenting the every expanding residential sectors – providing jobs closer to new commercial development, instead of individual towns producing pockets of successful development at a cost to neighbouring towns. 

It will also be interesting to see what happens in terms of the UK’s membership of the EU.  In either scenario there will undoubtedly be opportunities for growth, albeit for completely different reasons. 

So whilst Wellingborough faces some of its hardest challenges, the future is nevertheless exciting.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Tuesday, June 28, 2016


Daventry: more than just a logistics hub


Daventry: more than just a logistics hub

E-commence continues to fuel a boom in logistics says commercial property agent Prop-Search, with Daventry well placed to build on its already impressive ‘guest list’ of occupiers.

With many companies such as Amazon, Tesco and Sainsburys conscious of their carbon footprint – as well as growing road congestion – they have been keen to explore the viability of rail freight as part of their commitment to the most sustainable way of transporting goods across the country.  Prologis’s plans to deliver a 300 hectare expansion of Daventry International Rail Freight Terminal – DIRFT III – will certainly help the town attract more household names from this sector, looking to embrace the benefits of rail. 

The proposed third phase of DIRFT includes a rail link from the existing terminal to a replacement rail terminal, which includes new transhipment sidings, container storage and a HGV reception area.  The buildings will provide up to 7.86 million sq ft of rail served logistics and distribution floorspace – to be delivered over the next 15 years, resulting in the creation of 9,000 new jobs.  The first buildings are likely to be ready of occupation by the end of the year.

IDI Gazeley has recently completed the construction of a 297,320 sq ft warehouse unit at G Park, featuring a 12.5m clear internal height, 28 dock doors and three level access doors, 120 HGV parking spaces and 230 car parking spaces.  The company took the decision to speculatively construct this property given Daventry’s proven location for logistics – hoping to attract a company looking to expand into space close to the M1/M6/M69.

But it is not just e-commence and distribution companies that want to set up home in Daventry.  Figures obtained from a provider of online company formations showed that in excess of 650 new companies were established in the town during 2015.  So whilst Daventry has become a major hub for logistic operators, the town also has a well-balanced economy, generated by a broad mix of employment including a high number of independent businesses. 

Plans have recently been submitted for the construction of three new warehouses – totalling 345,000 sq ft – on land off Leamington Way, next to the Ford buildings.  The application from Canmoor Developments is for the redevelopment of the 22 acre site, previously occupied by a training centre, to create a high-quality development to suit the needs of local businesses.  It is hoped that this will act as a catalyst for the regeneration of neighbouring properties, bringing more new employment to the area.  The application also includes provision for 250 car parking spaces for workers, along with bays for deliveries by HGV.

Around 115 new jobs could also be on the way as Daventry District Council moves ahead with plans to expand the Marches Industrial Estate.  The Council has recently discussed opening up a new area of the industrial estate known as the Knoll; a patch of shrubs and trees in the centre of the estate, off South March.  The indicative masterplan for the 2.2 hectare site shows there could be up to seven units – five smaller ones and two larger – suitable for light industry or businesses.  The new units could provide a total of 29,000 sq ft of floorspace, with 115 parking spaces giving an indication of the number of jobs estimated to be created.

Elsewhere in the town, Hellmann Worldwide Logistics has committed to lease an 85,262 sq ft speculative warehouse at Prologis’ Apex Park.  Construction started at the end of August 2015 with completion imminent.  Hellmann will use the facility to service a number of new and existing customers.

Flooring Superstore, an expanding online retailer of carpets and flooring, has also invested a reported £650,000 in a new transport depot in Daventry that will create eight new jobs.  The firm says the investment in the new 10,000 sq ft facility on the Royal Oak Industrial Estate will allow for easier access and quicker delivery times. 

The town has unfortunately recently suffered one set back in its growth, with the 65,000 sq ft Mulberry Place retail scheme placed on hold.  This new town centre development, on land north of the High Street, was granted planning permission back in November 2013 and included a five-screen cinema and a new library – funded by Northamptonshire County Council.  However, this project has now been halted with the Council stating that it is not ‘economically viable’ at this time.

However, a redesign of a major retail site on land in the Waterloo/Gasworks/Chaucer Way area of the town – known as Town Centre Vision Site 5 – has been revealed.  The site received outline planning permission in June 2014 for a new large supermarket and petrol filling station but has now been revised – following many national supermarket chains shelving plans for new large store openings – to provide two smaller food stores, alongside six retail units.  The revised proposals also include a family restaurant, fast food restaurant, a 60-bedroom hotel and a McCarthy & Stone retirement housing complex.  Daventry District Council’s development partner Henry Boot Developments is expected to submit a full planning application shortly.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 / 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Tuesday, June 21, 2016


18th Century to modern day office location


18th Century to modern day office location

A building with roots dating back to the early 18th Century has had new life breathed into it following its conversion to a small business centre.

West End House at 60 Oxford Street in Wellingborough town centre was originally built as a substantial residence comprising coach house, stabling, pleasure garden, conservatory and out-buildings.  The house of coursed ironstone with ironstone ashlar façade, comprised three reception rooms, school room, 12 bedrooms, dressing room, bathrooms, kitchens and cellarage.  It became Grade II listed in the 1950s and converted to provide offices – home to various legal practices including Sharman Jackson & Archer and in more recent times Wilson Brown.

After standing vacant for a number of years, a local investment company purchased the building with the intention of undertaking a sympathetic refurbishment of the main building; retaining original features including panelled dados and marble fireplaces.  Phase one has now been completed and West End House Business Centre launched, providing independently-run offices for companies looking for flexible, professional space.  Additionally occupiers can enjoy access to meeting rooms and kitchen facilities, along with the ease of inclusive rental packages. 

Nick Morgan, a Director of R N Property Partnership LLP, said: “We had been looking for an investment opportunity in the area for a while and after serious negotiations we were able to secure West End House.  We felt that it ideally lent itself to offer individual rooms and suites to local companies – particularly in light of the closure of the Innovation Centre on Church Street.”

The Centre has already reported a strong level of interest from business occupiers keen to benefit from being located in the heart of the town centre and following a successful marketing period – by local commercial property agent Prop-Search – five companies have already taken offices within the building.

Utilities Direct, TDS Group, the Care Bureau took occupation during 2015 and have recently been joined by SEO Moves and the charity organisation, Family Support Group, which supports families and carers affected by a family member’s substance misuse.  FSL was founded in 2003 by a mother who herself was struggling to support a family member suffering from addiction, gaining full charitable status in May 2007. 
 

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director at Prop-Search, added: “I first became aware of FSL and the important work it does back in 2009 when it launched an appeal after losing its base in the town – following the amalgamation of the NSPCC’s Wellingborough operations into its Northampton office.  At that time I was able to identify new premises for the organisation and was delighted to assist them again with their relocation.”

Location is always a priority for FSL as it sees a lot of families and clients in the town centre, and West End House Business Centre was the perfect option being centrally located and with the benefit of on-site car parking.  It offers the charity much need expansion space to enable it to continue to provide counselling and confidential telephone support services, as well as general administration.

The West End Business Centre is now fully let.
 
Further information on other office opportunities or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Thursday, June 9, 2016


A more appealing investment?


A more appealing investment?

The UK’s commercial property market could become more appealing to a new breed of investor says commercial property agent Prop-Search, following Chancellor George Osborn’s announcement last year that buy-to-let and second home owners will be subject to a big tax hike –  as well as significant flexibility to the pensions system.

In his Autumn Statement, the Chancellor delivered a significant blow to residential investors saying that ‘people buying a home to let should not be squeezing our families who can’t afford a home to buy’ and introduced a three per cent increase in stamp duty.  Whilst perhaps three per cent does not sound like much, it in fact trebles the stamp duty bill on a £275,000 buy-to-let from £3,750 to £12,000.

Changes to the pension scheme – which came into effect in April 2015 – saw savers having the opportunity to withdraw large lump sums from their pensions to reinvest as they see fit, potentially in higher yielding assets such as property.  Whilst many may have automatically looked to the residential market for the traditional buy-to-let opportunities, the commercial property market could now hold significantly more appeal.”

Simon Toseland, a Director at Prop-Search, said: “At the beginning of last year, it was reported that over £59bn was invested in commercial property and indeed 2015 ended strong on investment thanks to the highest rental value growth since 2008.  In a recent report commissioned by the British Property Federation, it was also revealed that over seven million UK citizens have a retirement fund directly linked to the commercial real estate sector, as it offers stable, long term income and flexibility.”

When investing in commercial property, there are many factors that need considering before individual investors take that leap.  Typically there are longer tenancies available that can range from two to 15 years, compared to a typical residential property that is let on an assured short-hold tenancy, often as brief as six months.  The risk of void periods do occur and it can take longer to fill them in the commercial sector, because lease transactions are more complex.  However, on the plus side, commercial property can be seen as providing a more stable income as rents are often subject to upward only reviews.  And tenants, which are more likely to be companies rather than individuals, are also seen as less likely to default on rent payments and generally are fully responsible for keeping premises in a good state of repair and condition.

Simon Toseland concludes: “2016 is going to be a year of significant changes and big decisions in the buy-to let-market, and with that, the commercial property sector could become a much more enticing place for investors as they look for alternative returns on their funds.”

Wednesday, June 8, 2016


Corby: taking centre stage


Corby: taking centre stage

Just under half way through its 30 year growth plan, as set out in 2003, Corby is a town that is being transformed says commercial property agent Prop-Search, by continued investment and development – it now taking centre stage, not just in the County but also in the Midlands.

Corby’s revitalised town centre has bucked the trend throughout the recession and investment has continued with the opening of the new six-screen Savoy cinema during the summer last year.  This scheme is supported by restaurant operators Nandos, Prezzo and RBW – serving ribs, burgers and wings.

More retail development is planned in the town by Sovereign Land – the UK retail and leisure developer and asset manager – following its acquisition of the 800,000 sq ft Willow Place Shopping Centre and subsequent lettings.  Goddards, a high class ladies and gentlemen’s fashion retailer, has now taken 2,500 sq ft on a 10 year lease and Pep & Co, the UK’s new fashion clothing entrant, opening in 6,700 sq ft at 20 Willow Place.  Close by, a world food buffet offer trading as ‘Vaagabons’ has taken 2,500 sq ft at 3-5 Corporation Street on a ten year lease and Italgaleto, a regional ice cream and waffle retailer, 1,570 sq ft at 34 Corporation Street for a term of five years.

It is understood that Sovereign is currently implementing major new development and retail mix enhancement initiatives and is working on plans to deliver the next phase of development to the south east corner of the town – which is an important gateway entrance into Corby town centre.  The plan is to build on the current retail offer to attract new retailers and leisure operators who acknowledge the excellent opportunities of an expanding town.  Corby, recognised as one of the fastest growing towns in England, is seeing significant residential development with approximately 4,000 homes currently under construction and with plans for more than 28,000 new homes by 2020.

Out-of-town, proposals put forward by Aldi for a second store in the town has recently been approved by Corby Borough Council.  The premium discount food retailer purchased 3.17 acres of land at Saxon Way West for the imminent development of a 13,500 sq ft store with 123 parking spaces – anticipated to create 30 new full-time employment opportunities, as well as additional jobs throughout the construction and supply chain. 
 

Aldi took the decision to push ahead with its plans for a new store on this site following a consultation with members of the public last year.  It was deemed that a new food store in this location would serve the local community, provide a brand new custom store to complement the existing offering the town and provide more choice for local residents – with typical Aldi customers reportedly saving 30-40 per cent on their shopping.

Elsewhere, up to 40 new jobs could be created as Wickes commences the development of a new 25,000 sq ft retail warehouse on the corner of Courier and Cockerell Road, fulfilling its long-standing requirement for a new store in Corby.  The DIY giant purchased two acres within the 23 acre Manton Park scheme from Frenbury Properties for the construction of a new facility, which once open, will also accommodate a Wickes’ showroom focused solely on kitchens and bathrooms, supported by an installation service.

It is hoped that Wickes’ presence within Manton Park, located adjacent to the 114,000 sq ft Peel Retail Centre – anchored by Asda – and the Phoenix Park Industrial Estate, will act as a catalyst for encouraging further new development, investment and therefore additional job creation.  The scheme has planning for a variety of uses including warehouse, factory, motor dealerships and offices, with buildings available to purchase or rent on a design and build basis.  Alternatively, the developer will consider a sale of plots from one acre.

Corby represents an attractive proposition for businesses seeking to expand or relocate with commercial floorspace available, quality development sites and major opportunities for logistics firms at a number of well accessed sites across the town.  Indeed, at the end of last year Prologis secured CEVA Logistics for a 150,000 sq ft leasehold facility at Eurohub, managing the facility for the Swedish furniture giant Ikea.   It is believed that this deal netted a growth in rental value as demand for prime distribution space in the region continues unabated with logistics operators and retailers jostling for the best available locations – part of a trend that looks set to continue with an emphasis on internet retailing delivery and supply-chain efficiency.  It is believed more than 100 jobs have been created.

Changes in recent years to Corby’s infrastructure are certainly likely to have supported in town’s enhanced fortunes.  Over £40m has been spent on new road investment including dual-carriageway links to Rockingham in the north and the new A43 southern link road; with both projects delivering significant benefits for the logistics firms based in the town, while reducing the impact of traffic for residents.  This has no doubt assisted in the retention of larger multi-nationals based in the town including Benteler, RS Components and Staples.

With significant housing and commercial growth continuing in the town, as well as new and improved infrastructure and public facilities, Corby has done more than just weather the recession – it has grown and flourished – receiving a steady stream of inward investment, challenging outdated perceptions and creating future focused new ones.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 / 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Wednesday, May 18, 2016


Don’t hedge your bets


Don’t hedge your bets

A rule that has governed land boundaries for centuries has had another outing in the Court of Appeal says commercial property agent Prop-Search.

In this recent case, the Court had to consider the boundary between what had once been woodland – now houses – and a farm.  And in assessing the case, the judge applied the ‘hedge and ditch’ rule; a presumption that when digging a ditch along the boundary of land, the person digging the ditch will cut it to the extremity of his own land and throw the soil over his shoulder back onto his own land.  Commonly, a hedge will then be planted on top of the newly formed bank.

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director of Prop-Search, said: “In practical terms this means that where there is a hedge and adjacent ditch dividing the land of two neighbouring properties, the boundary line can be assumed to run along the edge of the ditch furthest from the hedge.”

In Parmar v Upton, the claimant Mr Upton owned the bulk of Birchy Farm near Solihull and Mr Parmar purchased land immediately to the south-east of this in 1997.  Following Mr Parmar’s residential development on his land, Mr Upton brought an action claiming that the development had trespassed on his boundary. 

Mr Parmar argued that the plan attached to the 1997 conveyance to Mr Upton indicated that the true boundary was the hedge and that therefore the ditch and the narrow strip of land between the hedge and ditch belonged to him. 

The Court of Appeal found that the judge in the County Court was correct to find that there was enough topography along the disputed boundary to permit the hedge and ditch rule to apply and there was nothing to rebut the hedge and ditch presumptions.  Furthermore, that the plan attached to the 1997 conveyance warned readers that it was for identification purposes only and therefore could not be relied upon as delineating the precise boundaries.

Samantha Jones concludes: “The case has given a good example of how the hedge and ditch rule is to be applied.  It also shows that the hedge and ditch rule continues to serve a valuable means of enabling neighbouring owners of rural land to avoid the invariably disproportions costs and stress of having to litigate boundary disputes.”

“However, this is not a hard and fast rule, it is a presumption and it is important to understand the make-up of the rule and to consider the history of the land or properties involved.  If for example, the ditch was dug when the fields were in the same ownership, the presumption cannot apply.  In those cases, the boundary is determined by the deeds but unfortunately often those are not detailed enough to easily answer the question.”

“It is important to remember that a poor quality plan from 30 years ago often isn’t clear enough to work out where the paper-thin line of the boundary actually is.  For example, a hedge on an Ordnance Survey map is a thin black line, but the hedge could be 10 feet wide – is the boundary on one side or the other, or down the middle?  And if someone is building houses, then 10 feet can make all the difference.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Wednesday, May 11, 2016


Rent Reviews – emerging from hibernation?


Rent Reviews – emerging from hibernation?

Following difficult market conditions since the credit crunch, when rent reviews all but disappeared, improved letting activity – in addition to taking the surplus stock out of the market – is, in certain sectors and locations, starting to demonstrate rental growth reports commercial property agent, Prop-Search, which looks set to continue.

One direct consequence is that savvy landlords are once again on the back of increasing economic confidence, contemplating invoking rent reviews due under leases, rather than merely being grateful for an existing rental income stream.

Ian Harman MRICS, a Director of Prop-Search, said: “Some landlords are also contemplating their position in respect of rent reviews which may have passed, but where the lease does not contain any clear provisions that time is of the essence, preventing matters from being re-visited retrospectively – although the valuation itself date will invariably be fixed.  To a great many tenants the ability to invoke a rent review which may be two or three years past, comes both as a nasty surprise and frequently gives rise to an unplanned financial liability.”

From a landlord’s perspective, care needs to be taken to ensure that the lease terms to be assumed for valuation purposes are consistent with the market and that the lease does not contain any restrictions, sufficient to impact on value and also that sufficient contemporary evidence exists to support their case.  In this respect, whilst post valuation date lettings are admissible as evidence, they will generally not be attributed the same level of weight as pre-rent review date transactions and will normally become less reliable the further away the date of the transaction is from the rent review date.

From tenant’s perspective, it is not always safe to automatically assume a rent review will be waived by the landlord.  It could be that securing professional advice is going to become an increasingly worthwhile investment, relative to the possible cash flow implications of having to fund a retrospective and unexpected rental increase.

Ian Harman adds: “Whilst locations and sectors are not performing in exactly the same way and properties need to be considered on a case by case basis, recent experience suggests that both landlords and tenants may both be missing out by not taking appropriate advice when rent reviews start falling due.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 / 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Monday, April 25, 2016