Investment in East Northants brings prosperity


Investment in East Northants brings prosperity

East Northamptonshire has certainly been put on the map in the past couple of years says Prop-Search, with inward investment pouring into the region, particularly through the representation of key retailers and businesses.  This sustained growth has continued to bring benefits for local people through job creation and overall improvement of prosperity.

The emphasis on the development of the visitor economy has be a key factor; a prime example being the inimitable Rushden Lakes shopping and leisure scheme, which is drawing people into the region, increasing tourism spending and bringing new employment opportunities.  It brings together the very best in retail, leisure and dining; set beside a 200 acre nature reserve and lakes with visitors able to enjoy shopping, walking, alfresco dining and a range of other leisure activities including cycling and canoeing. 

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director of Prop-Search, said: “Since the launch of Rushden Lakes in July 2017, it now comprises some 450,000 sq ft of built space, which has attracted local independents as well as many well-established major brands.  These include Marks & Spencer, Next, Primark, House of Fraser, Boots, JD Sports and White Stuff – as well as eateries such as Bills, Wildwood, Pizza Express and Bewiched coffee.”

This year the West Terrace has opened featuring a Cineworld IMAX 14-screen cinema and further leisure operators including 360 Play, indoor climbing centre Rock Up, Paradise Island Adventure Gold and Flip out trampoline park.  These are complemented by a further host of well-known restaurants such as TGI Fridays, Starbucks, Nandos, Heavenly Desserts, Five Guys and Zizzi.  Further openings from are expected later this year.

Flowing from the South Terrace, a landscaped piazza – known as the Garden Square – offers 10 further retail units, totalling 30,000 sq ft, which have already attracted inspiring brands such as Beaverbrooks, Skechers, Hotter, Jones Bootmakers and Three – with Barbour also expected to open shortly.   As the name suggests, Garden Square features a unique enclosed garden space for visitors to enjoy; the concept being to provide a quiet, green space for shoppers that could also be transformed into a location for outdoor events and pop-up shops. 

A prominent commercial site on the A6 bypass with John Clark Way, close to Rushden town centre, has been purchased by Birmingham based developer, Godwin Developments.  The 1.7 acre roundabout site is currently vacant and a planning application has subsequently been submitted, and just approved, for the development of a petrol filling station with drive-thru restaurant.  The end users are currently unknown.

A new retail development anchored by a Co-op convenience store in Irthlingborough has been purchased for £2.5m by Nottingham-based Bassi Property Group.  Built by Paragon Property Development Company, the new retail development comprises a 10,000 sq  ft space let to Central England Co-operative for a food store and funeral home which opened in November last year following the development’s completion.  The site was originally purchased in 2014 by Paragon Property and despite having a planning consent for a 40,000 sq ft Morrisons superstore, the site had remained vacant since 2007 when the former shoe factory was destroyed in a fire.

Situated on the popular and established Warth Park at Raunds, a high quality single let logistics unit of 42,528 sq ft has been acquired by Southampton City Council for £8.2 million.  The modern well specified ‘cross-dock’ unit was developed in 2013 and benefits from a minimum clear eaves height of 6m, 26 level access loading doors, 5 dock level loadings doors, 65 car, 10 HGV and 56 van parking spaces.  It is leases with an additional 19,886 sq ft overflow car park to DPD Group UK on two co-terminous full repairing and insuring leases – expiring 08 September 2033 – at £424,548 per annum. 

Also on Warth Park, with surrounding occupiers including Howdens UK Limited, AirWair International, DSV, Gem Distribution Limited and Asda, plans have recently been approved for a new £8m Enterprise Centre which is expected to create about hundreds of new jobs.  East Northamptonshire Council has secured permission from its own planning committee for a three-storey building which will be a hub for 90 start-up businesses.  The plans include a total of 27,000 sq ft of space, comprising 17,500 sq ft of offices and 9,500 sq ft of business starter units.  The current proposals also include a total of 114 car parking spaces.

The proposed Centre is specifically targeted at the needs of small businesses in the area and is part of the East Northamptonshire Council’s ongoing programme of development.  It is envisaged, based on the scale of this development and the current economic climate, that the proposed centre of starter units will provide support for a range of local businesses and approximately 200 people.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Friday, August 23, 2019


Opportunity to lease industrial HQ facility on new trade park


Opportunity to lease industrial HQ facility on new trade park

The success of the award winning Brackmills Trade Park in Northampton has been resounding, with but the unfortunate demise of the engineering arm of Monarch Airlines, the largest of the speculatively constructed units has now come back to the market.

Unit 14 – comprises a 23,124 sq ft detached HQ industrial/warehouse facility that was developed approximately two years ago and pre-let for use as a new component maintenance centre.  It was constructed to a high energy efficiency standard, achieving an Energy Performance Certification rating of A and boasts features including an 8m eaves height, two level-access loading doors, two-storey office and ancillary areas – situated within a self-contained and secure yard area.

Richard Baker, a Director of retained letting agent Prop-Search, said: “Brackmills Trade Park remains an exciting development for us to market and we are confident of attracting a new tenant for this prominent warehouse facility at the entrance to the Park.”

The 65,200 sq ft trade counter, retail and industrial/warehouse scheme – funded by M&G Real Estate – had achieved 100% occupancy, attracting an array of national occupiers.  This includes Screwfix, Pizza Hut, Auto Windscreens, Subway, Easy Bathrooms, Greggs, Dulux Decorator Centre, Howdens, Topps Tiles, Digraph Transport Supplies, National Windscreens and Costa. 

Further information can be obtained from letting agents Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 / www.prop-search.com or Avison Young – Tel: 024 7663 6888 / www.avisonyoung.co.uk

Monday, August 19, 2019


Northampton – strengthening its role


Northampton – strengthening its role

The growth in population, to a figure reaching over 200,000, has strengthened Northampton’s role as a major employment, retail and residential centre of Northamptonshire – retaining its position as the largest town in England, says commercial property agent Prop-Search.

Situated within the wider Oxford – Milton Keynes – Cambridge Corridor, Northampton has become an important centre for high performance engineering and high-end shoe manufacturing, and as a logistics and distribution centre.  Other areas that are also highly represented are in business administrative and support services, and financial and insurance activities with major employers include Barclaycard, Cosworth, Panasonic UK Ltd, Travis Perkins, Avon, Carlsberg UK and Nationwide Building Society.

Richard Baker, a Director of Prop-Search, said: “In recent years, the distribution and general industrial market has been the main thrust of the commercial property market, accounting for a substantial proportion of Northampton’s employment growth.”

The French based property investor, Barjane, has recently launched its first logistics development in the UK; a 257,000sq ft warehouse building at Brackmills Point, purpose-built for sporting goods retailer Decathlon.  The new site has proved a perfect location for Decathlon, which has relocated from a smaller 190,000 sq ft building nearby, in order to accommodate the increasing logistics requirement associated with its growing UK store network and online sales.  The new site also provides for expansion of up to 100,000 sq ft on adjacent land.

Also within Brackmills Industrial Estate, two retail warehouses, totalling some 336,000 sq ft have been purchased by the real estate investment company Warehouse REIT.  The properties are let to John Lewis, at a rent reported to be £1.83 million per annum and are operational critical to John Lewis in what is still an undersupplied part of the UK for mid box warehouses.

The ongoing requirement for the more traditional employment land, for general industry and offices, needs to continue to be accommodated.  This will ensure that there is a balance in the economy in terms of job supply across the sectors.  Northampton’s new Local Plan, which has recently been approved for consultation, has identified sites that have the capacity to deliver more employment growth. These include land within the town centre such as Four Waterside, as well as on Brackmills Industrial Estate, Swan Valley and Pineham, Moulton Park and Lodge Farm.

The retail market remains one of the dominant themes of discussion in the last few years, as town centres continue to experience higher rates of vacancies – national retailers closing down completely or some of their stores, and customer behaviour towards online retailing continuing to change.

Northampton has a compact town centre which performs a regional role within the County.  Apart from retail, other uses – including residential – have an important role to play towards ensuring the vitality of the town centre.  Whilst vacancy rates have fallen over the past ten years, the current level of empty shops gives rise to some concern given their spatial concentration.  The Council aims to maintain and enhance the vitality and viability of Northampton’s town centre by focusing investment which will help to promote their economic prosperity.

The Borough Council has recently applied for £25 million from the Government’s Future High Street Fund which could be used for redevelop part of the town centre.  A new taskforce – Northampton Forward – has been established and unveiled its submission to revitalise the town.  Among a host of proposals, such as a new indoor foodhall, the Council is looking to improve the visual appearance of town businesses at ground floor level with new, traditional shop fronts.  Money would also be offered to landlords to renovate empty offices units on upper levels or encourage repurposing of vacant properties.

Particular areas of focus within the submission include Market Square, Greyfriars, the eastern section of Abington Street, the route along Marefair and Gold Street, and the area around Fish Street and Dychurch Lane

Just outside of the Borough, work has started on construction of High Speed 2 (HS2), which will provide a high speed rail link between London and Birmingham – with a later phase proposed to link further to Leeds and Manchester.  An advantage of this for Northampton is that this offers potential to release capacity on the West Coast Main Line (WCML), with the possibility that new service patterns could be introduced – perhaps including fast, long distance services calling at Northampton. 

Richard Baker, added: “This would increase the range of destinations available and with Northampton in the heart of the Oxford – Cambridge Corridor, play an important contribution to the wider growth aspirations.  It will strengthen its role as a great UK location for a range of employment opportunities, as well as offering an excellent quality of life for its communities.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 / 01933 223300 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Friday, August 2, 2019


New legislation brings forward business rates revaluation


New legislation brings forward business rates revaluation

Business rates will reflect property values more accurately after a shake-up being introduced in new legislation says commercial property agent Prop-Search.

Following the reform, which was first unveiled in the Autumn Budget in 2017, local government minister Rishi Sunak has confirmed that property revaluations for business rates payers in England will increase to every three years from the current five years.  The next revaluation will be brought forward a year from 2022 to 2021.

Mr Sunak said: “We’ve listened to businesses asking for more frequent revaluations and are now acting so their bills will more accurately reflect current property values.  By bringing forward the next revaluation to 2021, we are making sure businesses can benefit from the change as soon as possible.”

Commenting on the change in legislation, Samantha Jones, an Associate Director of Prop-Search, said: “We welcome the confirmation of the move to more frequent revaluations which will undoubtedly mean more accurate rates bills for occupiers.  However, moving the three yearly revaluations will only work is the Valuation Office Agency has the manpower and IT to cope with the increased workload.”

A property’s business rates bill is determined by its rateable value, which is its estimated open market rental value on a set date.  This is assessed by the Valuation Office Agency in England. 

Samantha Jones concluded: As a property’s business rates bill is based on a precise estimate of the premises’ rental value, business rates revaluations help ensure this estimate accurately reflects the market value of the property and maintains fairness.  The 2017 revaluation was the first for seven years and in parts of the country and across certain sectors, led to huge increases for businesses.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Friday, July 19, 2019


A new era for Wellingborough


A new era for Wellingborough

Wellingborough over recent years has benefited from dominant warehouse and industrial markets, only curtailed by a lack of new development that has constrained supply says commercial property agent Prop-Search.  This supply imbalance has been eased slightly with a couple of significant buildings becoming vacant, as well a new development coming to fruition.

A prestigious HQ manufacturing facility on Park Farm South will be ready for occupation later this year following an extensive refurbishment programme.  The 91,000 sq ft property occupies a prominent self-contained site of 7.3 acres and was originally designed as a design and manufacturing facility with associated warehousing.  The staggered configuration of the accommodation allows for the logical and convenient allocation of dedicated operational uses, as well as the site being able to accommodate significant expansion, providing for a total floor area of up to circa 140,000 sq ft.

Having secured a £1.26 million grant from South East Midlands Local Enterprise Partnership (SEMLEP), Northern Trust last year completed a £4.4 million project to speculatively develop 42,420 sq ft of industrial space within the Leyland Trading Estate.  The 13 unit scheme provides units from 542 sq ft up to 8,928 sq ft and is already over 75% occupied.  New tenants attracted to the development include Alexander Media & Production Services, Carp Superstore, Hartley & Noble, Northampton Budget Crockery Hire and NJT Transport Solutions. 

Three units offering 2,771 sq ft to 6,696 sq ft remain available within the Estate; a popular location for a wide range of businesses, offering modern industrial/warehouse units, with generous parking and yard areas, and available on flexible lease packages.  The Estate also benefits from manned guarding, with dog patrols out of normal working hours and CCTV coverage to the security office – offering an enhanced security provision.

Simon Toseland, a Director of Prop-Search, said: “Wellingborough is slowly starting to experience growth through the delivery of Stanton Cross to the east of the town (Wellingborough East), with building work on the initial phase of the some 3,650 new homes well underway.  This is in addition to the employment opportunities in the form of new commercial buildings designed to make Stanton Cross a thriving commercial hub, providing flexible space for businesses ranging from international companies to local start-ups.”

The first phase of a 1.5 million sq ft development by St Modwen, through a collaboration agreement with Bovis Homes, is being promoted in the form of three warehouse facilities.  These offer accommodation from 40,000 sq ft to 275,000 sq ft.  It is understood that St Modwen will look at commencing speculative development of the scheme to achieve practical completion towards Spring/Summer next year.
A further new 80,000 sq ft scheme, which will also offer a business investment opportunity in Stanton Cross is now being promoted  Apollo Technology Park will provide for 36 individual commercial units, ranging from 1,600 sq ft to 3,800 sq ft, with greater sizes available in combination and feature multi-use two storey accommodation.

The development will be built on the former Brookside Garage site on Finedon Road by Apollo Business Parks which has already developed two other such schemes in Buckingham and Banbury.

A planning application will be submitted shortly, with early expressions of interest being sought, both on a leasehold and freehold basis and the option to configured units to suit occupier requirements.

Infrastructure works are progressing well on Glenvale Park; Wellingborough’s urban extension to the north of the town, which is set to deliver some 3,000 new homes along with schools, a community centre, nursery and a business campus.  The first phase of land sales are now complete; providing some 800 new homes for delivery in 2020 through to 2021.  These will be complemented by a new local centre, which will include a family public house to be operated by Marston, a convenience food supermarket pre-let to the Co-op and a care home.  A mix of other neighbourhood centre retail opportunities are now available in units from 1,000 sq ft to 5,000 sq ft. 

To the south of the town, plans have recently been revealed for a new £33 million marina at The Embankment, which include waterside residential accommodation, shops, restaurants, bars and office accommodation, alongside 48 hour moorings for narrowboats and cruisers, a hotel and a river taxi service linking the town to nearby Rushden Lakes. 

A feasibility study for this exciting scheme has been drawn up after Wellingborough Council awarded the Nene Valley Catchment Partnership a £15,000 grant last year to look at potential projects for the waterside area.  The current plans identify projects to improve the commercial, recreational, aesthetic and environmental status of the area, and have been tabled following the formation of a working party, which includes the Wellingborough Chamber of Commerce, the River Nene Regional Park CIC, Nenescape, Nene Valley Catchment Partnership and a number of other groups and individuals passionate about the future of the River Nene and surrounding environment.

Simon Toseland adds: “The marina project is just one element of the overall vision that was borne out by the efforts of the Wellingborough Waterside Working Group.  These also included other initiatives including improved access and amenity, improvements in ecological status and enhanced protection for the environment. “

The scheme is in the very early stages, with the next steps being further consultation with agencies such as Natural England, the Environment Agency and Highways before a planning application can be prepared and submitted. 

Wednesday, June 26, 2019


High Court rules against lease frustration


High Court rules against lease frustration

Whilst many in Britain are becoming frustrated with Brexit, the High Court has recently rejected a claim by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) that Brexit was grounds for lease frustration – a result which has been welcomed by the property industry.

The European Medicines Agency (EMA), a medicines regulator responsible for authorising and monitoring medicines in the EU, had argued that the lease on its Canary Wharf HQ had been ‘frustrated’ by Britain’s impending departure from the EU.  It claimed that Brexit was an unforeseeable event which, because of the extent to which it is intertwined with EU institutions and member states, frustrated the 25 year lease which it entered into in 2014.  And that as a result of Article 50 being invoked, relocated to Amsterdam.

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director of Prop-Search, in explaining lease frustration said: “Frustration is a legal doctrine which renders a contract incapable of being performed due to an unforeseen event – after the contract has been entered into – resulting in the obligations under the contract being radically different from those that were contemplated by the parties.  Frustration ends the contract with immediate effect.”

The claimant landlord, Canary Wharf Group (CWG), disagreed with EMA’s interpretation of frustration and to avoid uncertainly, commenced proceedings seeking a declaration from the Court that the lease was not frustrated by Brexit.

Mr Justice Marcus Smith upheld the landlord’s views and in his judgement concluded that EMA’s lease would not be frustrated by Brexit, since the EMA would enjoy continued powers until 2039 to assign or sub-let the premises – even if it would not enjoy those powers under EU law that made no difference to the English law analysis – and any frustration would have been self-induced by the EMA in any event.”

Samantha Jones added: “In summing up, the Judge concluded that the EMA remained obliged to perform its obligations under the lease – a decision that came as a welcome reassurance to commercial landlords of property leased to European tenants.”

“However landlords can only breathe a small sigh of relief as subsequently the EMA has been granted permission to appeal the High Court’s decision.  The case will now be heard by the Court of Appeal with a date scheduled for March 2020.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Thursday, May 30, 2019


Corby: Food for thought


Corby: Food for thought

With Corby excelling in capturing demand from food processing and packing companies, it is no surprise to see this trend continuing says commercial property agent, Prop-Search, with the town having a strong history in shift work – a counter to the perception of being unionised.

Such companies already based in the town include Mademoiselle Desserts, a cake a desserts manufacturer with a turnover of 260 million; Oakhouse Foods, which makes frozen ready meals; and Blue Sky Holdings, a salad producer which relocated from Kent to a 50,000 sq ft facility.

These important employers are now complemented by Jacksons, which has opened its new £40 million state-of-the-art bakery on a 10 acre site on Genner Road, on the Willowbrook Industrial Estate.  The Hull based business, part of the William Jackson Food Group, announced last year that work was to start on the facility in Corby – specifically designed to make bread for sandwich manufactures and foods service customers.  Fifty jobs have reported already been created at the factory, which supports Jackson’s main bakery, in Hull that produces some two million loaves a week, including Jackson’s Yorkshire’s Champion brand.

At the end of last year, multi-temperature supply chain and logistics specialist Oakland International confirmed it is to invest a further £2.8 million in a high-bay extension to its Corby facility on Eismann Way.  The decision to expand in Corby is as a result of the site’s strategic ability to fulfil the company’s core distribution requirements for a number of large UK retailers.

The company launched in Corby in March 2017 and has since developed its relations with the Corby Borough Council and its Planning Department, which has given the company a great confidence boost and played a significant part in its investment and further growth in the Corby region.  Working in conjunction with its landlord, Norwich Council, the extended hub will deliver a multi-temperature proposition to the market for chilled, frozen and ambient storage, and the company plans to support the development by recruiting wherever possible within the local area by the end of the year.

Construction is also likely to commence this year on the development of a prime 1.5 acre site on the Southern Gateway Business Park – to be forward funded by a private investor – to deliver 7,800 sq ft of retail accommodation.  Pre-lets have already been agreed to provide for a McDonalds Drive-Thru restaurant, Costa Drive-Thru facility, a Domino’s Pizza outlet, with serious enquiries on the last remaining unit of 1,000 sq ft being progressed.

Following the announcement last year of a deal to forward fund a new £81.8million, 844,000 sq ft distribution centre for Eddie Stobart – one of the UK’s leading logistics businesses working across the full supply chain in the UK and Europe – Tritax Big Box REIT plc has announced a further multi-million deal at its Midlands Logistics Park.  Contracts have reportedly been exchanged, conditional on receiving full planning consent, to provide a new 945,375 sq ft national distribution centre for BSH Home Appliances Limited, part of the Bosch Group.  The Bosch Group is the largest manufacturer of home appliances in Europe and one of the leading companies in the sector worldwide with high quality brands that include Bosch, Gaggenau, Neff and Siemens.  The development represents an investment of £89.3 million, reflecting a net initial yield of 5.2%

To the east of Midlands Logistics Park, plans have now been submitted to Corby Borough Council for a new warehousing development on 400 acres of land at Cowthick Plantation on Stamford Road.  Greatline Developments Limited and Mulberry Developments have submitted an application, which if approved, will give consent for the construction of up to 4.35 million sq ft of warehousing and ancillary buildings, predominately aimed at the distribution logistics market.  Unit sizes are likely to range from 575,000 sq ft up to just over one million sq ft.

As activity shows, Corby is fast becoming the new hot-bed for logistics companies, with land supply tightening within the ‘Golden Triangle – where the M42, M1 and M6 motorways meet – and occupation costs rising.  Being strategically located alongside the A14, Corby’s popularity has increased in recent years with local road improvements, such as Phase 2 of the Northern Orbital Road, also benefitting several employment sites, as has its strong history of shift work and migrant workers.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

 

Wednesday, May 22, 2019


Lofty expansion leads to warehouse opportunity


Lofty expansion leads to warehouse opportunity

With successes such as the installation of the famous Christmas tree at Trafalgar Square in London and projects such as the Waterloo Station Super Puma helicopter plant lifts and the bridge installation on the Bedford bypass, it is not surprising that Radius has sought the need for larger premises in Northampton.

The company can fulfill any crane project in the UK, whether it be to supply a tower crane – through its partnership agreement with NFT – or managing and consulting on a variety of projects.  Radius has acquired a modern detached warehouse facility on Gladstone Close through Prop-Search.  The facility totals just under 39,700 sq ft on a 3.3 acre site and is fitted to a good specification with some 5,000 sq ft of offices, and large self-contained yard area.

Radius has subsequently instructed Prop-Search to list its former premises; Equilibrium House at Mansion Close, on the Moulton Park Industrial Estate.  The HQ hybrid business unit comprises 10,000 sq ft and has recently been comprehensively refurbished to include two-storey offices of approaching 4,000 sq ft providing a mix of open plan and cellular accommodation, prestigious reception and well-appointed staff facilities.  The detached property occupies a site of approximately half an acre and offers 22 linear car parking spaces.

Prop-Search is seeking to let the facility on the basis of a new lease agreement, with terms to be agreed and is quoting a guide rent of £70,000 per annum exclusive.

Further information can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Thursday, May 16, 2019


Innovate product company joins line-up at prestigious office scheme in Corby


Innovate product company joins line-up at prestigious office scheme in Corby

UK Innovations GP Limited, a small UK based business specialising in the creation of innovative problem solving products, has joined an impressive line-up of occupiers within one of Corby’s most prestigious office schemes.

The 25,000 sq ft Blenheim Park office development – located in the ever-popular Oakley Hay business area – is already home to a array of local, regional and national businesses including including AG Retail Cards (Clinton Cards), Friday Legal, Peavey, NRI Civils, Wilfrid Smith and Marray & McIntyre.

UK Innovations has recently agreed terms to occupy Oak House, a two-storey building within the scheme offering 1,330 sq ft of refurbished air-cooled offices.  The accommodation has been leased through commercial property agents Budworth Hardcastle and Prop-Search, acting on behalf of the landlord.

UK Innovations is relocating from premises in the town to meet with its existing business requirements.  It retails innovative and problem solving products such as anti-snoring devices, hair care products including heat free hair straighteners, gel eye masks, wine accessories, and pet play and comforters.

Further opportunities to lease accommodation within Blenheim Park remain, with offices available in suites from 853 sq ft, to whole buildings of 3,154 sq ft or combinations of both up to approximately 11,500 sq ft.  The scheme is able to deliver high speed broadband up to 85Mb, and all offices are newly refurbished and ready for immediate occupation.

Further information or advice can be obtained from Amanda Lawrence and Gilbert Harvey at Budworth Hardcastle – Tel: 01536 483400 or Samantha Jones and Richard Baker at Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or the scheme’s website: www.blenheimparkoffices.co.uk

 

Monday, May 13, 2019


What one does is what counts


What one does is what counts

To coin Pablo Picasso’s words “What one does is what counts – not what one had the intention of doing”, has never been truer says commercial property agent Prop-Search, as the Supreme Court rules on one of the most significant property law cases in many years.

In the case of S Franses Limited v Cavendish Hotel (London) Limited, the Cavendish Hotel, located near St James’ Park in West London, had refused a tenant’s request for a lease renewal – on the ground and basement floors of its hotel – on the basis that it wished to carry out redevelopment works under Section 30(1)(f) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954.  The tenant was S Franses Limited, the well-known and historic textile dealership and consultancy.

In short, Section 30(1)(f) of the 1954 Act entitles a landlord to refuse to grant a new lease to a tenant on the grounds that it intends to carry out works to the premises.  Before this case, the landlord only needed to demonstrate a firm and settled intention to carry out the works and a reasonable prospect of carrying out that intention.

In this case, the Cavendish Hotel devised a disruptive £920,000 scheme with the sole purpose of obtaining possession to satisfy ground (f).  It was admitted that the proposed works would not be carried out if the tenant left voluntarily, but nonetheless gave an undertaking to the Court, that it would to carry out all of the works if vacant possession were ordered.  The works would prepare the premises for conversion into two retail units for which planning permission would also be needed and the landlord intended to proceed with the works regardless of whether it could obtain planning permission and even if the works would have to be undone or reversed.

Samantha Jones, an Associate Director at Prop-Search, said: “Previously, a landlord’s motive was not considered relevant to ground (f).  However, the Supreme Court has held that the absence of any other motive, but to remove the tenant, was evidence that the landlord did not have the ‘firm and settled intention’ required to satisfy ground (f).  Instead, it had merely a conditional intention in that it only intended to carry out the works in order to satisfy ground (f), but would not do so if the tenant left voluntarily.”

Ground (f) is probably the most used ground of opposition to a request by a tenant under the 1954 Act for a new tenancy.  It is a long established tactic for landlords – even those with genuine motives – to ‘beef up’ their programme of works by adding more material alterations, to ensure that they satisfy the substantiality requirement of ground (f).  However, following this judgment, the tenant can challenge whether the landlord has the requisite intention to carry out those additional aspects of the works, based on whether the landlord’s sole motive for those aspects is to ensure ground (f) is satisfied.  If a tenant were to be successful, those aspects of the works would be disregarded by the Court.

Samantha Jones concluded: “The ruling provides a new basis for a tenant to challenge whether its landlord’s proposals are conditional and may increase the tenant’s chances of remaining in occupation of its business premises.  On the flip-side, landlords will need to consider their position more carefully before seeking to refuse a tenant a new tenancy on the grounds of redevelopment.”

Further information or advice can be obtained from Prop-Search – Tel: 01933 223300 / 01604 492000 or its website: www.prop-search.com

Thursday, March 28, 2019